English First News and Notes
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Updates on official English and related issues

Thursday, May 29, 2003
 
Smoking Gun in Puerto Rico?

The League of United Latin American Citizens was a big backer of Puerto Rico statehood during the Clinton Administration. There was some talk at the time that LULAC's interest was a product of cold, hard cash. Today, we learn:

GDB reveals Rossello distributed funds improperly
Thursday, May 29th, 2003.

SAN JUAN (AP) – Government Development Bank (GDB) First Vice President Minia Gonzalez said former Gov. Pedro Rossello improperly distributed the funds from the tobacco industry settlement, which should have been assigned to the Children Trust Fund.
Gonzalez said in published reports that in 1999, Rossello gave $328 million to the Education Department, $60 million to PRISMA exploratory laboratory for children, and $409,232 to the Citizens League for Latin American Citizens [emphasis added].

None of the entities filed proposals for funds, had complete budget reports, or other certifications required by the Treasury Department.

|posted by Jim on 5:57 PM| Link
. . .
Monday, May 19, 2003
 
New E.O. 13166 Column

was issued today by conservative leader Paul Weyrich. A sample:

Oh, by the way, I asked Boulet if my taxes were audited, could I have it done in ancient Aramaic since Jesus told us to render unto Caesar what is Caesar's, and as a practicing Christian, it would be nice to have that done in the same language my Lord actually used. Boulet replied that that was "an open question."


|posted by Jim on 6:10 PM| Link
. . .
 
Puerto Rico's Sharpton Caucus

Advocates of Puerto Rico statehood in 1998 argued, quite seriously, that a 51st state of Puerto Rico would be quite conservative -- the equivalent of Oklahoma. According to Roll Call, a newspaper that devotes itself to covering Capitol Hill, one of the leaders of the Puerto Rico statehood effort, Jose Serrano (D-NY), plans to endorse presidential candidate Al Sharpton:

The endorsement would make Serrano the first Member of Congress to back the fiery street preacher, who is one of nine Democrats to declare for the 2004 presidential nomination thus far.

Serrano cast his support for Sharpton, who has carved out a niche at the left end of the field, as a means of helping to ensure that the reverend remains viable through the primaries.

This, he hopes, will force the other contenders to fight for backing from liberals who represent the most committed segment of voters in the party.

"I want the Democrats to be Democrats," Serrano said of the presidential field. "Without Sharpton, they start to talk like Republicans."

Now we find out that a 51st state of Puerto Rico would mean a "Sharpton caucus" of at least seven new Representatives and two Senators in Congress.

|posted by Jim on 6:05 PM| Link
. . .
Friday, May 16, 2003
 
A Last, Amusing Star Trek Item

With all the discussion of Klingon translation here this week, I thought you might enjoy Happyfunpundit.com's "Top 10 Things I Hate About Star Trek", which was spotlighted in National Review Online's "The Corner" today.

|posted by Jim on 6:11 PM| Link
. . .
 
New Trial Because Juror Did Not Understand English

In Wisconsin. This is not the first time the problem has come up.

In some cases, interpreters are provided to the jurors. But that may create more problems than it solves:

there is the expense. State-certified interpreters, most of whom speak Spanish or Navajo, are paid $30 an hour, said Fern Goodman, general counsel for the state Administrative Office of the Courts.

Another problem, [district attorney] Martinez said, is the possibility of mistranslation. She said in the past, both she and a Spanish-speaking judge have disagreed with an interpreter for a witness or a defendant.

Translation is not an exact science as this comparison of translations of Aristophanes demonstrates.

|posted by Jim on 3:56 PM| Link
. . .
Wednesday, May 14, 2003
 
Funny Translation Errors

Here.

|posted by Jim on 8:45 AM| Link
. . .
 
More Government Translation Errors

The Sierra Club reports:

One stumbling block to putting up warning signs in the [San Francisco] Bay Area was as prosaic as finding someone who could typeset Chinese, Cambodian, and Korean. In addition, the Cambodian translation turned out to be in the wrong dialect and thus completely offensive to its target audience.

|posted by Jim on 8:32 AM| Link
. . .
Tuesday, May 13, 2003
 
Where Do People Speak What?

Map.

|posted by Jim on 7:50 PM| Link
. . .
 
Oregon Klingon Update

Via National Review Online.

I am reminded of the Oakland School Board's 1996 proposal to offer instruction in what they called "Ebonics." Absolutely everybody complained -- even, for a time, Jesse Jackson. So the School Board announced they wouldn't be teaching black children in Ebonics and the press went away. Only all they did was drop the term "Ebonics."

As I documented for NRO today, simply stopping a search for a Klingon interpreter, as Oregon has said it has done, does not mean that the issue is closed. Alll that is needed is one request for translation into Klingon to trigger E.O. 13166 anywhere.

|posted by Jim on 6:12 PM| Link
. . .
Monday, May 12, 2003
 
Klingon Language Institute

Yes, there really is such a thing.

|posted by Jim on 4:16 PM| Link
. . .
 
What Does Klingon Sound Like?

Klingon says "Nuq'nH" ("what do you want?") on the last link of this page. A complete Klingon pronounciation guide can be found here.

|posted by Jim on 4:14 PM| Link
. . .
 
Is Klingon Translation Really Required By Law?

Yes. Title VI Prohibition Against National Origin Discrimination As It Affects Persons With Limited English Proficiency (Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights, August 30, 2000) states:

In the course of its enforcement activities, [HHS] OCR has found that persons who lack proficiency in English frequently are unable to obtain basic knowledge of how to access various benefits and services for which they are eligible, such as the State Children's Health Insurance Program (SCHIP), Medicare, Medicaid or Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) benefits, clinical research programs, or basic health care and social services. . . .
In order to ensure compliance with Title VI, recipient/covered entities must take steps to ensure that LEP persons who are eligible for their programs or services have meaningful access to the health and social service benefits that they provide. The most important step in meeting this obligation is for recipients of Federal financial assistance such as grants, contracts, and subcontracts to provide the language assistance necessary to ensure such access, at no cost to the LEP person (emphasis added).

The way this policy guidance, as well as other E.O. 13166 documents, are written, necessity is determined by the patient, who is infinitely free to complain about inadequate language services no matter what costly translation is done on his behalf. Language was not part of the 1964 Civil Rights Act but is now, thanks to E.O. 13166. Congressman Peter King (R-NY) has introduced legislation (H.R. 300) to repeal E.O. 13166, which you can support here.

|posted by Jim on 11:09 AM| Link
. . .
 
Oregon Seeks Klingon Speakers

The Department of Human Services for Multnomah County, Oregon, is seeking speakers of over 50 languages, including Klingon in order to comply with Clinton Executive Order 13166:

"We have to provide information in all the languages our clients speak," said Jerry Jelusich, a procurement specialist for the county."

Keep in mind that the E.O. 13166 translation requirement applies to people who may speak English perfectly well, but simply prefer to communicate in Klingon, Latin, Esperanto or Urdu.

"There are some cases where we've had mental health patients where this was all they would speak," the county's purchasing administrator, Franna Hathaway told the press. County officials said that obligates them to respond with a Klingon-English interpreter.

The folks who invented E.O. 13166 for Bill Clinton remain employed by the Bush Administration Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights where they are deciding precisely how E.O. 13166 shall be enforced.

Given that E.O. 13166 applies to any institution which receives one dollar of federal funds, doctors and hospitals nationwide will be relieved to know that Klingon classes are now available via interactive multimedia CD.

|posted by Jim on 10:32 AM| Link
. . .
Saturday, May 10, 2003
 
Snatching Victory From Defeat

On May 7th, freshman Congressman Steve King (R-Iowa) proved once again that simply asking for a roll-call vote can turn a defeat into an easy victory. According to CQ Today, the chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, James Sensenbrenner (R-Wisconsin), urged that no amendments be offered to a bill which would make the families of deceased war heroes eligible for citizenship.

King defied his own chairman by offering an amendment to limit the citizenship benefit to family members “lawfully present” in the United States. Sensenbrenner, as well as committee Democrats, went ballistic. The amendment was crushed by voice vote. King could have given up. Instead, he insisted on a recorded vote. Suddenly the amendment passed handily, 14-8.

Other conservative Congressmen, please take note. As a disgruntled Minnesota Viking fan said, circa 1993, "I don't mind when they lose. I mind when they don't even try."

|posted by Jim on 2:34 AM| Link
. . .
 
What is Wrong With the Archives?

I found out this Thursday that the archive feature of this weblog no longer works. Blogger has put in some new code which I can not get to function properly. Anyone with ideas or suggestions, e-mail me at blogger@englishfirst.org. If I need to replace Blogger with something else more nontechnical-user friendly, I will do so.

|posted by Jim on 2:16 AM| Link
. . .
 
Why Postings Declined

Out of respect for the war situation, I decreased postings here considerably. But as things settle down in Iraq, I will be back far more often.

|posted by Jim on 2:10 AM| Link
. . .
 
Liberalism Translated

I have good friends who disagree about the Iraq war. But this translation of liberal Protestant church-speak against that war is priceless.

|posted by Jim on 2:08 AM| Link
. . .
 
Talk Show Postponed

Alan Colmes interview now set for Monday, May 12, 10:15 Eastern time. I am told I will be debating a Miami school board member. Should be fun.

|posted by Jim on 2:05 AM| Link
. . .
Friday, May 09, 2003
 
Florida Students Demand Achievement Tests in Spanish

WorldNetDaily.com reports today that some Miami high-school students think they should be given their achievement tests in Spanish. One student, Jessica Duran, actually complains: "I want to be a doctor and because of that [English-only test] I can't do it." What next? Miami students demand Spanish-only medical schools.

I am scheduled to discuss this issue on the Alan Colmes radio show tonight at 10:15 PM. You can listen via the Internet on Alan's home page.

|posted by Jim on 5:05 PM| Link
. . .
Wednesday, May 07, 2003
 
West Wing Rewrite

Ever since The West Wing concluded a season by using Dire Straits Brothers in Arms as background music as the Bartlett staff walked behind their president, I've been a watcher. Our numbers are in steep decline this season. Blogger Patrick Ruffini has come up with a way to save The West Wing from ratings extinction. Alas, no mention of Dire Straits.

|posted by Jim on 5:19 PM| Link
. . .


. . .