Monday, September 30, 2002
How to Show Support for "Minorities" in MA?
From Minority supporters of O'Brien dissatisfied," Boston Globe, September 30:
Adrian Durbin, [Democrat gubernatorial candidate Shannon] O'Brien's press secretary, also criticized Thomas, insisting that O'Brien enjoys strong support among minority voters. After campaign appearances in Roxbury, Dorchester, and Lawrence, as well as advocacy for bilingual education, Durbin said, O'Brien has demonstrated her commitment to minorities" (emphasis added).
|posted by Jim on 4:34 PM|
Link
. . .
Update on CO, MA Bilingual Education Referenda
|posted by Jim on 4:23 PM|
Link
. . .
Thursday, September 26, 2002
AP: "30 States Have Multilingual Ballots"
In Denver County, Colo., officials are worried about finding 200 bilingual poll workers by November, said Alan McBeth, spokesman for the Denver Election Commission. So far, they've got just 60.
Officials also haven't figured out how to fit a Spanish-language version of the ballot on voting machines' electronic screens, which can display only a limited amount of text, McBeth said.
Election Commissioner Jan Tyler estimates Spanish assistance will add up to $80,000 to the more than $500,000 it now costs to conduct an election. Denver will comply with the requirements, but Tyler — the granddaughter of Polish immigrants — doesn't agree with them.
"It's un-American to have to print ballots in other languages," she said. "I empathize completely with the immigrant experience. I still believe that people should learn to speak the language."
|posted by Jim on 11:37 AM|
Link
. . .
Spanish as a Political Tactic
The October Washington Monthly has a lengthy and interesting article on language matters by Liesl Schillinger entitled "Spanish Disquisition Or, how a bookish Gringa learned to stop worrying and love el idioma."
A sample:
The Harvard student who learned Spanish in 1975 often did so to follow Che's motorcycle route on a South American road trip. The girlfriend who accompanied him might have studied French, but she didn't want her boyfriend to think she was a snob, so she took Spanish instead. She wanted to seem like a woman of the people.
Like the girlfriend, today's politicians have found that a Spanish vocabulary is useful for disguising silver-spoon roots and expressing solidarity with the masses. Our president, George W. Bush--who comes from a famously privileged background and had a diplomat-class upbringing--demonstrated this in May at a press conference in Paris, when he scolded an American news reporter for having had the effrontery to ask President Jacques Chirac a question in French. Bush huffed to the crowd, "Very good, the guy memorizes four words, and he plays like he's intercontinental." When the reporter, stunned by the hostility, countered that he knew many more than four words of French, the president's disgust only mounted: "I'm impressed. Que bueno (how great)," he said snidely. He clearly meant it to sting--a not-so-veiled suggestion that the reporter was a member of the effete liberal class that was responsible for all that's wrong with American politics. At his birthday this July in Kennebunkport, Bush wore a baseball cap printed with the words "El jefe" (the chief). The message was clear: French is poncey, show-offy, elitist. But Spanish is all-American.
Schillinger, with an obvious knack for learning languages, also states:
No lesser an authority than Paul Fussell, author of the Bible of the American caste system, Class, told me, "I believe quite sincerely that in 50 years Spanish will be the absolute equal of English as a social and financial and serious alternative to English in this country. America will be bilingual, absolutely. The bright people will be." My fervent hope is that, despite my newfound love of Spanish, the bright people will be trilingual--English, Spanish, and something else, too.
The attitude expressed here appears to be "what I like to do and can do easily, everyone else must also do" and it is not unique to Schillinger. At a meeting on bilingual education held at the Center for Applied Linguistics this week, I met a woman from Iceland who said she spoke eight languages. Guess what she does for a living? That's right -- bilingual education coordinator.
This strikes me as one of the reasons why bilingual education does not work. It was a creation of language mavens and political activists. Each group had its own reasons for pushing immigrant children to maintain the ancestral tongue. But the students now trapped in bilingual education programs who lack a gift for languages are doubly burdened.
Gifted people making education policy for all were the reason for the "new math" of the 1970's: "Addition and subtraction? How dull! Let's talk about sets and number theory." I spent a year in grade school moving colored wooden pieces of various sizes about and learning to derive the principles of mathematics from alien number systems. As the Internet joke making the rounds goes:
Teaching Math in 1950: A logger sells a truckload of lumber for $100. His cost of production is 4/5 of the price. What is his profit?
Teaching Math in 1970: A logger exchanges a set "L" of lumber for a set "M" of money. The cardinality of set "M" is 100. Each element is worth one dollar. Make 100 dots representing the elements of the set "M." The set "C", the cost of production contains 20 fewer points than set "M." Represent the set "C" as a subset of set "M" and answer the following question: What is the cardinality of the set "P" of profits?
Bilingual education makes the perfect (learn two or three languages) the enemy of the good (learn English well).
|posted by Jim on 11:25 AM|
Link
. . .
Florida Elections: Failure is Never Final
A lawsuit has been filed demanding a rerun of Florida's Democratic primary races. More are expected.
|posted by Jim on 10:35 AM|
Link
. . .
Words Matter
Lynn Chapman, State Vice President of Nevada's Eagle Forum, taught me this past weekend that we should never refer to politicians as "the government" because we are "the government." They are "public servants." This homeschooling mom knows the Constitution better than do many in Washington, D.C.
|posted by Jim on 10:30 AM|
Link
. . .
Great Link for Political News
If you haven't bookmarked ABC News' The Note yet, you should.
|posted by Jim on 10:25 AM|
Link
. . .
Bilingual Education Major Issue in Massachusetts' Governor's Contest
The Boston Globe reports that Milt "Romney backs the Unz initiative, and rolled out a campaign ad last week in which the Republican pledges to ''end the failed idea of bilingual education in our schools and teach children English instead.''
|posted by Jim on 10:01 AM|
Link
. . .
Agnosticism on Bilingual Education
As Colorado prepares to vote on bilingual education, the Denver Post asks the obvious question: Does bilingual education work?
|posted by Jim on 9:55 AM|
Link
. . .
Tuesday, September 24, 2002
Report From Eagle Council
Eagle Forum held its Eagle Council this past weekend in Virginia. Eagle Forum founder Phyllis Schlafly has been a great friend on official English issues like bilingual ballots and E.O. 13166.
I had a chance to chat with some Eagle Forum activists and came away with several good ideas. A Washington State attendee reminded me that, since many cell telephone calling plans now include free long distance, it is worth programming your cell phone with the telephone numbers for Congress (202) 224-3121 and the White House comment line (202) 456-1111.
|posted by Jim on 5:19 PM|
Link
. . .
FL Ballot Vexing
|posted by Jim on 5:07 PM|
Link
. . .
Thursday, September 19, 2002
Election Reform Redux
Today's Roll Call carries an update on the status of election reform in Congress. My take on the subject also appears today in National Review Online.
|posted by Jim on 10:58 AM|
Link
. . .
Tuesday, September 10, 2002
Primary Day
The Justice Department will be sending monitors to ensure non-English speakers can still vote in the New York and Florida primaries today. Has anyone told them that even government election documents written entirely in English can contain mistakes?
|posted by Jim on 2:18 PM|
Link
. . .
Saturday, September 07, 2002
A Bilingual Education Teacher's Approach to 9/11
In the absence of sufficient Spanish language material, I gravitated toward images, which can be discussed in any language one chooses. I also felt compelled to help students examine photos of the war on Afghanistan because, especially in those early days of bombing, the media did not portray with either words or pictures the suffering that must have been occurring in Afghanistan as a result of the U.S. attack.
|posted by Jim on 2:41 AM|
Link
. . .
CO Bilingual Education Ban Update
"The Denver school board asked voters Thursday to reject Amendment 31 in November . . . The Boulder, Poudre and Jefferson County school boards also have passed resolutions against Amendment 31," reports the Denver Post.
|posted by Jim on 2:20 AM|
Link
. . .
Understatement of the Year in FL
Dalis Guevara, "a bilingual occupational therapist for the Osceola County [FL] School Board and a first-time poll worker in Kissimmee this year" told the Orlando Sentinel: "Hispanics complained to me, saying they couldn't properly vote [in 2000] because nobody there spoke Spanish," said Guevara, who is among a large group of Puerto Ricans who live in Osceola County. "Voting is completely different in Puerto Rico."
No doubt. Fully 90% of Puerto Rico residents speak little or no English.
|posted by Jim on 2:17 AM|
Link
. . .
CO: Bilingual Ballots Increase Election Costs Nearly 20%
The Denver Post reports that a Department of Justice requirement of bilingual ballots throughout Denver and "bilingual polling judges in heavily Spanish-speaking precincts . . . could raise the cost of elections in Denver by as much as $80,000, officials estimate. A general election in Denver now costs taxpayers about $500,000."
Who benefits? People like "Maria Miera, who has worked as a polling judge in Denver . . . [and as] a secretary at a private bilingual school in Denver. Miera "wanted to tell the Justice Department that it shouldn't back off pressure on the city to comply with new bilingual voting requirements." After all, if Denver is required to provide bilingual polling judges, Miera's Election Day compensation is likely to increase, and increase substantially.
|posted by Jim on 1:58 AM|
Link
. . .
|
. . .
|